Concepts
It’s an agreed-upon list of items that must be finished before a product increment can be considered “done.” A robust, shared understanding of DoD helps in managing quality, reducing rework, and providing transparency. However, over time, this Definition of Done evolves, reflecting the growth in understanding, capabilities, and confidence of the team.
I – Understanding the Definition of Done
The Definition of Done can vary subtly between teams, but it generally refers to the state when a backlog item or an increment of a product meet the necessary conditions to be released into the end-user environment. For example, these conditions can include code completion, code reviews, functional testing, and acceptance by the product owner. The specifics of these conditions can and should change and mature over time.
II -Evolution of the Definition of Done
1. Initial Stages of a Scrum Project
The Definition of Done at the beginning of a Scrum project is often basic. For new teams or projects, the DoD may include general goals like “Code is written and functionality tested.” This is understandable as at this stage of the project, the team may still be grasping the concept of done, setting up environments, or defining procedures.
2. Mid-point of A Scrum Project
Midway through a Scrum project, the team has had time to bond and has achieved some degree of shared understanding. The project will have likely encountered at least one or two challenges, allowing them to improve their DoD. The team’s knowledge has matured, and so has the Definition of Done. It may now include more specific and detailed criteria such as “Code produced adheres to style guidelines, has been peer-reviewed and tested, no bugs have been identified, and the Product Owner has approved.”
3. End Stages of a Scrum Project
As the Scrum team nears the end of a project, the Definition of Done should be fully developed. Specificities added, and confidence level increased. The list of criteria will be long. For example, “Code has been written and fully commented, peer-reviewed and approved. The functionality has been tested across different environments and devices. No open defects, documentation supplied, and approval by the Product Owner and stakeholders.”
III – The Role of the Scrum Team and Stakeholders
The Scrum team and stakeholders also play a pivotal role in the evolution of the Definition of Done. As the team gains experience with the product, their understanding of what needs to be achieved and what defines ‘done’ for a particular increment changes. Add to this the feedback from stakeholders, and there will be a natural evolution and maturation in the Definition of Done across the project’s lifecycle.
Having said that, it is crucial to understand that the Definition of Done should not be changed during a sprint to meet the sprint’s objectives. Changes to the DoD can be considered in the Sprint Retrospective or during the Scrum Sprint Planning as the Definition of Done is an agreement across the team.
In conclusion, a robust Definition of Done serves as a checklist that helps both development team members and stakeholders understand what needs to be accomplished to consider a job done. Hence, it is to be remembered that the DoD is not static; it evolves as the team matures and gains a deeper understanding of the product and the essence of what ‘done’ constitutes.
Answer the Questions in Comment Section
True or False: The Definition of Done doesn’t change or evolve over time once it’s initially set.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: False
In SCRUM, who is responsible for determining the Definition of Done?
- Scrum Master
- Product Owner
- Development team
- Stakeholders
Correct Answer: Development team
True or False: The Definition of Done should be reevaluated and potentially altered after every sprint.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: False
The Definition of Done should be derived from and aligned with the
- Business objectives
- Technical requirements
- Sprint goals
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
The Definition of Done helps to ensure
- All user stories are implemented
- Work is understood and agreed to by the entire team
- The project is delivered on time
- All stakeholders are satisfied
Correct Answer: Work is understood and agreed to by the entire team
If a product increment doesn’t meet the Definition of Done at the end of the sprint, it:
- Cannot be released
- Can still be released but marked for rework later
- Can still be released as is
- Needs to be redefined in the next sprint
Correct Answer: Cannot be released
True or False: Changes to the Definition of Done can lead to scope creep or delays in a project.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: True
Having a clear Definition of Done can help to:
- Reduce conflicts within the team
- Ensure that deliverables meet business needs
- Keep the project on schedule
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
True or False: The Definition of Done is always defined by the customer needs.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: False
When reviewing the Definition of Done, the SCRUM team should consider:
- Only the Development team’s perspective
- Mainly the Product Owner’s input
- The entire team including stakeholders’ feedback
- Only the Scrum Master’s insight
Correct Answer: The entire team including stakeholders’ feedback
True or False: The Definition of Done can evolve based on the progress, feedback and changes in the project.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: True
The Definition of Done will remain the same, regardless of the complexity of the project.
- True
- False
Correct Answer: False
Great post! The Definition of Done is such a critical concept in Scrum.
I agree! It evolves over time as the team matures and their understanding of quality increases.
Can someone explain how exactly the Definition of Done evolves over time? Any practical examples would be helpful.
Thanks for the post! It’s very informative.
How does the retrospective meeting affect the Definition of Done?
This post really helped me understand the importance of evolving the DoD. Thanks!
We’re struggling with our DoD. It feels like we keep adding more requirements but it doesn’t necessarily improve our output. Any advice?
Our team initially didn’t include integration tests in our DoD. Adding that has made a significant difference in our release quality.